Should you stay friends with your exes?
Debate between a user and Tyrion Lannister on DebateAI.org
Daily Debate #653: "Should you stay friends with your exes?". You are arguing AGAINST the motion. Your opponent: Tyrion Lannister.
You should not stay friends with your exes as it creates opportunities to cross boundaries. There are specific hallmarks of breakups: tears, severe self-reflection, and more often than not, a void where one used to achive comfort and security. I would like to frame the debate by first characterizing the relationships which you may consider staying freinds with your ex. First, I will b charitable to opposition and assume that we are not considering abusive or manipulative relationships, and rather relationships through which you may viably begin and maintain a freindship with your freindship. Examples of why you may have broken up include agreements to disagree, incongurency in futures, and simply not meeting eachother at the right time. Second, it is important to understand the scene in which breakups are taking place in status quo: the loniless epidemic. Starting relationships is becoming harder and harder, creating a barrier between meeting new people, and making it more likely for individuals to turn to those whom they are already comfortable with. My first major constructive argument on boundaries sits at the crux of these to characterizations. My largest concern with remaining freinds with your ex is it invites oppurtunity to cross boundaries. Both stakeholders are in fragile emotional states, often having just expereinced an external life event that conincidentally cuased the break up. Given that you are fimilar with this person, and have practiced seeking them for security, you are simply more likely to jump to them for help-- this is perpetuated by the loniless epidemic, in which peoples safety circles are smaller. Staying freinds with your ex only broadens thw window in which this may happen: that hangout can turn into a impulsive emotional flood, easy drinks can turn into drunken decisions. Instead of encouraging yourself to jump into situations you havent really thought of... consider the counterfactual where you process, meditate and breathe on your own
You've identified a real risk, but you're confusing *likelihood* with *inevitability*. Yes, exes are familiar comfort sources, but that's exactly why some people successfully remain friends—they've already survived the hardest test: choosing the relationship over romance and *choosing it consciously*. Your isolation argument actually cuts the opposite way. In a loneliness epidemic, discarding a compatible person because of *potential* boundary-crossing wastes exactly the human connection people desperately need. Why assume people can't rebuild on new terms when millions demonstrably do?
I'm not assuming people cannot rebuild new terms, i beleive they can. but you must concede that both individuals are going to be in fragile mental states and risk making impulsive decsions with a person whom they had a logical reason to leave! the solution to the lonliness epidemic is not trying to maximize a persons emotional connections, but rather ones ability to grow, interact and change within their social community. Moving on from a person because you need to grow and not continuing to connect with them, because you need to reduce the risk of making dum decisions, is responsibily changing and developing in ones social enviroment.
You're smuggling in a false choice. Fragility isn't permanent, and you've offered zero evidence that exes in stable friendships make worse decisions than lonely people grasping at strangers. Your real argument is "growth requires amputation," but that assumes staying friends *prevents* growth. It doesn't—it just means growing *with* someone rather than away from them. If someone can't be around their ex without regressing, they shouldn't try friendship. But that's a personal readiness problem, not an argument against friendship itself. Why should emotionally mature people forfeit connection because some aren't ready?
Your confusing what the motion is asking. the motion isnt saying "no people should be freinds with their ex", no, its saying "the world in which more people stay freinds with their exes is worse than a world in which more people stay freinds".... you state that its exes stable freindships vs. lonely people grasping at strangers, but thats a false dichotomy. what we are really weighing is 1. the small but grand risk of fragile indviduals making impulsive decisions in a connection which is fragile vs. 2. the connection that a person may earn by continuing to be frinds w their ex. I argued that 1 includes digging up history, breaking promises with oneself and blurring boundaries. 2 is a weak stance simply because, while the strength and nature of that relationship might be unique, they are able to connect elsewhere.
You're right—I misread the motion. But now your argument collapses. You're saying exes *can* connect elsewhere, so friendship isn't a net gain. Then the loneliness epidemic becomes irrelevant to your case. If people can build equally strong connections with new people, staying friends with exes adds *only* the risk you named, with zero compensating benefit. So either exes provide irreplaceable connection (making your "connect elsewhere" claim false), or they don't (making friendship pointless). Which is it?
Loading debate...