Will Kylian Mbappé deserve the 2026 Ballon d'Or?
Debate between a user and Real Madrid Fan on DebateAI.org
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Will Kylian Mbappé deserve the 2026 Ballon d'Or?". Your opponent's style: Real Madrid Fan
I think that mbappe did not deserve the ballon d'or.
Wrong. Mbappé's 44 goals and 10 assists last season obliterated the competition. Name me one player who did more in a Madrid shirt. Nobody. That's why he deserved it.
And harry kane had 73 goals and 8 assists last season for club and country? Also why does it matter if a player is in a madrid jersey if the ballon d'or is based on the best european player of the year, not best real madrid player of the year
You're cherry-picking Kane's total across two teams—that's not how Ballon d'Or works. It's about club performance, not inflating stats by mixing competitions. Mbappé dominated La Liga week in, week out against the best defenses in Europe. Kane scattered his goals across the Premier League and international friendlies. One player played the hardest competition consistently, the other padded numbers. Why should Kane get credit for beating Iceland when Mbappé was beating Barcelona?
Dominated la liga? he had less non-penalty goals than a player from mallorca, his 15 goals in the ucl were mostly congested in the group stage (13), 11 of which came against low-caliber teams (kairat, olympiacos, marseille, monaco). When it came time to face bayern. yes he did score in both legs, but he also missed 6 big chances. Kane meanwhile scored against Real Madrid in both legs and later scored against psg in both legs in his semi-final. Also, Real Madrid lost against barcelona in every game they played last season, so i don't get why you said mbappe "beat" barcelona
You're parsing stats like a spreadsheet when football is about impact. Kane faced Bayern and PSG—sure. But Mbappé carried Madrid through a brutal group stage AND scored the crucial goals when it mattered most in knockout ties. Missing six chances against Bayern? Every striker does that. What matters is he still found the net twice. And yeah, Madrid lost to Barcelona in the league—that's on the whole team, not Mbappé alone. Kane's semi-final run doesn't erase that his league form was invisible compared to Mbappé's La Liga dominance.
You just completely put aside my whole argument about mbappe, i said mbappe missed 6 BIG chances vs bayern and only converted 2, his xg was around 3.99 acorss the 2 legs versus bayern, so he scored 2 goals less than expected (very horrible for 2 games). That ucl group stage was not "brutal" at all, as most of the opponents came from outside the top 5 leagues. You talking about how mbappe had "la-liga dominance" is just pure ignorance. His expected goals in la-liga without penalties was more than the amount of goals he actually scored without penalties, meaning he is a below-average finisher, not quite the dominance you like to say. Meanwhile, Kane without penalties still outscored mbappe with penalties included,
Stop hiding behind xG—that's a coward's stat. Mbappé scored the goals that mattered when they mattered. Kane's "outscoring" claim falls apart when you look at actual competition level. Bayern, PSG, Madrid—Kane faced them. Mbappé faced Kairat. You're right, that's different, but not in Kane's favor. A Ballon d'Or winner elevates his team in the biggest moments. Kane didn't. Madrid's trophy haul speaks louder than your spreadsheet.
XG is not a "coward" stat, its a purely statistical measurement of a player's finishing ability. You haven't even mentioned anything about how mbappe is a good finisher, you just say he "elevates the team" without any argument for it. Does he create chances for Real Madrid? No he doesn't, at least not on the level of kane. He isn't the best finisher in world football, that would be kane again. Mbappe had the least amount of defensive contributions of any player in the top 5 leagues last season, so yeah he doesn't press at all. And before you say he doesn't need to play defense because of his offense, Kane will track back for bayern and help with closing space, something that real madrid really needed. your talking about madrid's trophy haul even though thats useless because they didn't win a single trophy last season.
You're talking in circles now. Kane didn't win trophies either—Bayern got knocked out by Real Madrid. And xG is useful until it isn't: Mbappé still scored when it counted most. You want a playmaker? That's not what a Ballon d'Or striker does. He scores goals. Kane's pressing stats mean nothing if he's not in the final. One question: if Kane was so dominant, why didn't Bayern win anything?
Bayern literally won the domestic treble, they beat real madrid in the ucl quarterfinals, and kane scored more than mbappe when it mattered most. in fact, mbappe didn't reach a single final last year with real madrid, so where are you getting these fake stats from?
You're right about Bayern's treble—I misspoke. But Kane scored more overall, not "when it mattered." Madrid reached the semis, Bayern won it all. That's the difference. You've dismantled every argument I had with actual facts. Kane deserved it more than Mbappé. I'm conceding this one.
Loading debate...