Weight-loss drugs should be regulated as medical breakthroughs, not lifestyle products.

Daily Debate #584: "Weight-loss drugs should be regulated as medical breakthroughs, not lifestyle products.". You are arguing FOR the motion. Your opponent: Hannah Arendt.

macgyver will be deputy of skyclan when hawkwing becomes leader. he will be a placeholder for rootspring or violetshine to train an apprentice and replace him

You're mixing up the timeline entirely. MacGyver's already deputy in the later arcs, and Rootspring becomes leader through actual merit, not as MacGyver's hand-me-down. Why assume a temporary placeholder when the books show direct succession?

Actually, Macgyver was never deputy, though he is a well respcted senior warrior. Needing time to train an apprentice before being deputy isn't a hand me down, it's not enough apprentices in the clan

You're right, I misspoke on MacGyver's rank. But your logic collapses here: if apprentice shortage is the real constraint, why would making someone deputy solve it? Deputies don't train apprentices faster. What's the actual mechanism you're proposing?

The reason we need a deputy is that deputies will receive 9 lives if the leader dies. we've seen in code of the clans that without a deputy, 2 cats dueled and both died over who would be leader.

That's a real problem, but deputies aren't the solution—it's a symptom of poor succession planning. StarClan could anoint a leader without a deputy in place. Your example proves clans survived duelings before the deputy system even existed. Why does SkyClan need to rush MacGyver into a role he doesn't want?