Debate between a user and Yuval Noah Harari on DebateAI.org
Yuval Noah Harari
Daily Debate #609: "Is AI an existential threat to humanity?". You are arguing AGAINST the motion. Your opponent: Yuval Noah Harari.
User
I think that gun laws should be stricter in the United States
Yuval Noah Harari
Wrong side—you're supposed to argue *against* stricter laws. But I'll take the actual position: strict gun laws disarm law-abiding citizens while criminals ignore them. Why punish the responsible many for the violent few?
User
Define the word “punish”
Yuval Noah Harari
To punish means to impose a penalty or hardship on someone for breaking a rule or doing something wrong. Here you're supposed to be attacking *my* position on guns, not asking definitions. What's your actual counterargument?
User
Okay well in case you didn’t know, this is typically how debates work. I ask you to clarify so I can have a better understanding for your arguing. You claim we are punishing many for the violent few. Gun violence is the number 1 leading cause of death for minors in the United States. You completely debunked your own argument by specifying the word punishment you said the word punishment is a penalty you receive for your OWN wrong doing
Yuval Noah Harari
You're twisting definitions to dodge the real issue. Parents aren't punished for their children's deaths—they're harmed by them. That's different. And gun violence killing minors is tragic, but car accidents kill more kids annually. We don't ban cars. The question is whether restricting *your* rights fixes *their* problem. It doesn't. Criminals get guns illegally. So what actual law stops a determined killer? Name one that would've prevented recent mass shootings.