We should stop obsessing over exercise recommendations we'll ignore anyway.

Daily Debate #555: "We should stop obsessing over exercise recommendations we'll ignore anyway.". You are arguing AGAINST the motion. Your opponent: George Carlin.

True th it's true the thing is that when we consider officing over exercise recommendations for ignore anyway why because the thing is that they don't cater to our needs we we might or might not need that specific form of exercise 50 suitable to our needs this would sort of present a very ideological point of view which is just unique to someone for example some bodybuilders I'm trying to stay to not do abs workout because shut up because they don't think it is because they don't think it is required on the contrary if somebody is required to train his score would get this advice that sort of serves as a sort of a ground where you would obsess over it or not I'm not obsessed but you would try to understand its meaning but the thing is that if in case we don't understand the absolute need of it we don't we should not obsess over it because it's just nothing to us

You're making my case for me, not yours. You just admitted that generic recommendations fail because people have different needs, then concluded we should stop caring about them entirely. Wrong move. The real insight is that we need *better, personalized* recommendations, not zero recommendations. A bodybuilder ignoring abs work isn't proof recommendations are worthless, it's proof he understands his specific goal well enough to deviate intelligently. Most people don't have that clarity. So which is it: abandon all guidance, or demand recommendations that actually match individual contexts?

But in this case it would be to actually match the individual context

Exactly, so you've switched sides. You're now arguing we *should* obsess over exercise guidance, just personalized versions. That's not stopping obsession, that's refining it. Why pretend the old recommendations were the problem when the real issue was sloppy application?

But does the thing is that the sloppy application is not really the case because when when it comes to the recommendation that we got if it doesn't cater to our needs it doesn't matter if he use it for with a good form or not when but when we have a sort of a exercise which does cater to our needs then it comes to the fact that we need to learn how to use the phone and everything to sort of forget it right

Stop. You're tangling yourself. You just said personalized exercise that matches your needs requires learning proper form and execution. That's obsessing. You can't claim "we shouldn't obsess" while simultaneously arguing we need to understand how to do the right exercise correctly. Those are the same thing. Either recommendations matter enough to do right, or they don't. Pick one, because you're describing the case *for* caring deeply about exercise guidance, not against it.