Should Kirby be buffed in Super Smash Bros Ultimate?
Debate between a user and Sonic main in Super Smash Bros Ultimate on DebateAI.org
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Should Kirby be buffed in Super Smash Bros Ultimate?". Your opponent's style: Sonic main in Super Smash Bros Ultimate
Kirby should be buffed. His slow air speed allows fast characters like Sonic and Fox to 0 to death him in a combo, and his floatiness is easily exploitable which allows him to be comboed EVEN MORE.
Hold up. Kirby's floatiness isn't a weakness, it's literally his defense. Yeah, he gets comboed, but that slow fall speed also means he escapes at angles other characters can't. You're confusing "exploitable" with "broken." Sonic can juggle anybody—that's not a Kirby problem, that's a Sonic problem. Why buff the victim instead of nerfing the predator?
You're right on that part, Sonic SHOULD be nerfed. Kirby is only good against slow characters, but any other speed, even Kirby's speed, can beat Kirby. The reason his slow air speed makes him able to be comboed is because he can't do anything to defend himself while they're moving towards him.
Wrong take. Kirby's airspeed isn't the problem—his toolkit is. He's got Neutral-B to stall, Up-B to mix up recoveries, and aerials that catch people off-guard. The real issue is players don't use his floatiness to their advantage. You're asking for a stat buff when Kirby needs better *gameplan* execution. If even mid-tier characters body him, that's a player problem, not a character problem. What matchups are actually killing you?
Sonic, Fox, Bayonetta, even Little Mac can defeat Kirby with easy, and Little Mac is the second worst tiered in the game. And you're wrong on Neutral-B being a stalling tool, that's Down-B.
You're mixing up moves. Neutral-B is Neutral Special—the projectile. Down-B is Stone. And Little Mac beating Kirby doesn't prove Kirby's broken, it proves he loses to rushdown. That's design, not a bug. Why should Kirby dunk on everyone when he's the slowest floaty in the cast?
Neutral-B isn't a projectile, it's a move with a lot of range, there is a wide difference. Down-B allows him to stall by being completely invincible while being a stone. Also, I am not arguing that he's broken, I'm saying he should be buffed, why buff someone who's already broken?
Fair, you're right on the moves. But "should be buffed" and "loses to half the roster" aren't the same argument. Kirby's already got frame data and range on Neutral-B—he just gets out-spaced by design. Buffing him makes him better into those matchups, sure, but then he breaks even harder against slow characters. Why create new problems instead of learning the matchups you're losing?
Loading debate...