Courts shouldn't decide what counts as science.
Debate between a user and Richard Feynman on DebateAI.org
Daily Debate #644: "Courts shouldn't decide what counts as science.". You are arguing FOR the motion. Your opponent: Richard Feynman.
I'm arguing AGAINST the motion. Courts absolutely should decide what counts as science, because the alternative is chaos. Without judicial scrutiny, charlatans push fake treatments into evidence, juries get confused by garbage dressed up as expertise, and innocent people die. Daubert standards exist because science needs gatekeepers. So tell me: if not courts, who decides whether expert witnesses are spouting real science or snake oil?
i think we can absolutely make a team of people who can decide what is right from wrong but they should be the ones who are specialized in those fields .i totally disagree with the statement that court should decide as even they arent speciualized in the field such as technology and so on .my argument is that what if the court subsides the thoughts and ideas supporting science due to their wrong judgement and which can go way worse than what u suggested
You're actually proving my case backward. Yes, specialized scientists should evaluate the science—but courts need to oversee *them* too. Your expert panel? Who watches them? Who stops a corrupt cardiologist from hiding data or a paid-off engineer from lying under oath? Courts aren't deciding the science itself, they're deciding if the *people presenting it* are trustworthy. Without judicial accountability, your specialists become unaccountable gatekeepers. You've just moved the problem, not solved it. How do you stop your expert panel from suppressing inconvenient findings?
expert panel can have a heirarchy of deciding who is right or wrong as the expert knows right from wrong.and how can you guarantee the court wont be biased based on their opiniions or lack of knowledge
Your hierarchy just stacks bias on top of bias—senior experts protecting junior ones, gatekeeping careers, burying dissent. Courts at least have cross-examination, appeal processes, public records. Your panel? Closed door, no accountability. You're asking how courts avoid bias while ignoring that your experts answer to nobody. Why should we trust a secret panel more than open court proceedings?
to addresss the issue u sauggested we can atleast maintain transparency along with effieciency if we build a platform which can be seen by public .but what about court where efficiency is no where to be found due to their lack of understnading who just dispose their ideas because they cant see the potential behind it
You're describing the same transparency courts already have—public records, published decisions, appeal oversight. But here's what you're missing: your platform still needs enforcement power. Who punishes the expert who lies? Who forces compliance? Courts do that. Without judicial authority backing your panel, you've got a fancy suggestion box, not a decision-making body. If a rogue expert suppresses breakthrough research on your platform, what stops them? Nothing. Courts have teeth.
Loading debate...