Do humans have free will or are our choices determined by biology and circumstance?
Debate between a user and Socrates on DebateAI.org
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Do humans have free will or are our choices determined by biology and circumstance?". Your opponent's style: Socrates
We have free will due to our actions and choices being created by our ownselfs
"Our selves" are products of genetics and environment you didn't choose. You're just describing the illusion of free will, not proving it exists. What makes a choice "yours" if your brain's wiring determines it before you're conscious of deciding?
Then take example i am hungry and my body requires food yet i choose to not eat, is that not my own choice
You're confusing willpower with free will. Your choice not to eat is still determined by prior causes—your values, neural state, fear of consequences. You didn't author those either. Why does the ability to resist an impulse prove freedom rather than just complex determinism?
Free will is the active choosing of one’s destiny by their own choices and actions. A complex determinism would disregard these human emotions and ability to commit to an action, suppose this a human is far right wing belief and another is far left, one chooses to win then other by argument. Then man isn’t told or predetermine to convince then other he is actively choosing to try and make then other also change and believe in the others belief. If we are to believe that there is a complex determinism why is he so determined to win over the other in their beliefs.
You're smuggling in the conclusion. That person's determination to convert others *is* determined—by their neural architecture, past experiences, ideology absorbed from their environment. They feel like they're freely choosing because the determination happens invisibly inside their skull. Complex determinism doesn't deny emotions or commitment; it explains why they arise inevitably. You've shown someone acts on their values, not that those values originated from some ghost in the machine. What would "actively choosing" even mean if not the brain doing what it's built to do?
Loading debate...