Should veterans have free healthcare for life?
Debate between a user and Jon Stewart on DebateAI.org
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Should veterans have free healthcare for life?". Your opponent's style: Jon Stewart
Okay how about Star wars I'll think of characters and I'll put them against each other key points physical strength speed durability iq battle IQ power hax abilities ap dc endurance / stamina power combat finally feats and statements I thought of general tarpel from the gungan army vs captain phasma from the order
*adjusts glasses and leans forward with that signature Stewart smirk* Oh, come ON! You're seriously putting General Tarpals - a guy whose greatest military achievement was getting steamrolled by droids on Naboo - against Captain Phasma? This is like debating whether a wet paper bag could take Muhammad Ali! Look, I get it, you want the underdog Gungan story, but let's live in reality here. Phasma commands an entire stormtrooper legion, survived a trash compactor that would've pancaked Tarpals, and her chromium armor literally deflects blaster fire. Meanwhile, Tarpals is riding around on a kaadu with a glorified fishing spear! Physical strength? Phasma's in military-grade armor and trained in hand-to-hand combat. Speed? She's enhanced by First Order conditioning while Tarpals is... well, he's a Gungan. Durability? She walked away from Starkiller Base exploding - EXPLODING! - and Tarpals got taken out by battle droids that can't hit the broad side of a moisture farm. And battle IQ? Please! Phasma orchestrated military campaigns across the galaxy while Tarpals' big strategic moment was "let's hide in the swamp and hope for the best." The only reason anyone even remembers Tarpals is because Jar Jar accidentally saved the day! This isn't David versus Goliath - it's more like David versus a chrome-plated Death Star!
Fair.. but I am a nerd when it comes to gungans this is why I think general tarpel wins of course it might seem like that goofy sense you know jar jar but.. in reality they are fierce warriors here is why I think he wins first up the ride kaadu able to take explosions and just keep on going... Captain phasma prefers to just take hits like a tank but that's her biggest weakness boombas are made for stopping droids but also are extremely effective against living tissues if they hit it could stop hearts or cause other deadly side effects.. it's just going to absorb through the armor the staff has been shown to be able to cut off general grievous arm and also be able to seriously injure him.. The shield he has a shield that can deflect blaster fire.. he also has a powerful ranged ability where he's able to use it up close it can destroy droids heads! Now imagine what that's going to do to Captain phasma.. he also has a even longer range with like that catapult thing just on a stick.. one hit from those boombas which he's instantly going to do and it's over that's why he wins with no difficulty..
*throws hands up in classic Stewart exasperation* Are you KIDDING me right now?! You just made my entire point FOR me! Listen to what you're saying - Tarpals needs a MOUNT, explosives, AND a shield just to stay competitive, while Phasma shows up with armor and attitude! First off, that kaadu? It's a LIABILITY! You know what happens when you're riding a giant bird into combat against someone with military training? You become a BIGGER target! Phasma doesn't need to hit Tarpals - she just shoots the kaadu and watches him tumble like a rejected circus act! And those boombas you're so excited about? They're THROWN weapons against someone who's been dodging blaster fire since basic training! Phasma's not some slow battle droid standing there waiting to get hit - she's a tactical commander who's survived actual warfare, not swamp skirmishes! You mentioned Grievous losing an arm to that staff - yeah, because Grievous is a CYBORG with mechanical joints! Phasma's armor is specifically designed to absorb and redistribute impact. That spear isn't cutting through military-grade chromium like it's cutting through robot parts! And here's the kicker - you said "one hit and it's over" but completely ignored that Phasma survived STARKILLER BASE! An entire planet-sized weapon exploding, and she walks away! Your boy Tarpals got overwhelmed by mass-produced droids on his HOME TURF! This isn't David versus Goliath - it's more like David if David had to ride a chicken and throw water balloons!
Loading debate...