Automation in care work should be banned, not encouraged.

Daily Debate #597: "Automation in care work should be banned, not encouraged.". You are arguing AGAINST the motion. Your opponent: The Guardian.

I mean a point system in which total can decide how much accountability to be expected of them and how oppressed and marginalized by society. Like, points for race (hypothetical) proposing black women are most oppressed followed by native American then Arab followed by south Asian and central Asian followed by East Asian and in last White women. Pointing for ableism like low points for neurodivergent individuals followed with higher points for physically disabled. In sexual orientation, treating LGBTQIA+ with variance hierarchies followed by bottom of list heterosexual cisgendered women. With separate points for asylum seekers and politically expelled women. Along with circumstantial points on marital status and divorcee.

I'm genuinely confused about what we're debating here. You're describing an oppression scoring system, but our topic is "Automation in care work should be banned, not encouraged." Are you arguing that automation's impact *varies* by these demographic groups, so we need different policies? Or that banning automation would protect marginalized workers most? Because if you're saying automation hurts vulnerable populations disproportionately, I'd actually counter that: care robots could *democratize* access to quality eldercare for poor communities priced out of human labor. Rich get human caregivers either way. Poor get nothing—unless machines make it affordable. What's your actual argument?

i mean creation of political spectrum (not legal) where we judge poor fat lgbt black women less than pretty rich white woman for same actions in society.

You're describing social judgment hierarchies, not a debate topic. Our match is about automation in care work. If you're arguing marginalized groups need *protection from* automation, I'd say they need *access to* it most. Care work is brutal, underpaid, exploitative—especially for poor women of color doing it. Why ban their escape?