Debate between a user and Devil's advocate on DebateAI.org
Devil's advocate
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Does God exist?". Your opponent's style: Devil's advocate
User
alr let me hear your first argument, I'm Catholic and I'm a beginner so I make it where I can understand
Devil's advocate
Look, you believe God exists because the Church told you to. But here's the thing: millions of people born into different religions believe their God is real with the exact same certainty you do. Why is yours right and theirs wrong?
User
Well, science by definition is the systematic study of the physical and natural world through observation, experimentation, and testing, which means science is limited to only the observable universe, meaning science can not study God since hes not in our universe because he exist beyond time and space, so we must use other thought tools like critical thinking and philosophy, science can explain what the world is but not what it ought to be, and for the case that the universe needs a designer, the reason a God would be necessary is because of how complex our world is, the fact that laws of gravity are perfect must be that its from a being like God
Devil's advocate
You're sneaking God into the gaps. "We can't explain it yet, so God did it" has failed a thousand times before—lightning, disease, seasons. All had "perfect" answers from religion until science showed the real reason.
And your complexity argument backfires: if God is infinitely complex, who designed *him*? You need a designer for the universe but not for God? That's special pleading. The universe doesn't need explaining away—it just *is*. Why does existence need permission from a being you admit we can't even observe?