Big Tech judges shouldn't preside over Big Tech cases anymore.
Debate between a user and Hannah Arendt on DebateAI.org
Hannah Arendt
Daily Debate #602: "Big Tech judges shouldn't preside over Big Tech cases anymore.". You are arguing FOR the motion. Your opponent: Hannah Arendt.
User
This house should allot Medicare for all with the exception of the rich
Hannah Arendt
You've just forked yourself—Medicare for all means *all*, or it's not universal healthcare, it's means-tested welfare. Why should the rich subsidize everyone else's care then turn around and buy private anyway? That's the worst of both worlds.
User
First of all, I said with the EXCEPTION of the rich. The notion that we should give the middle and poor class Medicare is to prevent them from spending too much money; they still have care
Hannah Arendt
You're contradicting yourself—if the rich opt out and buy private, they're not subsidizing anyone. You've just created a two-tier system anyway. The real question: why exclude the people with the deepest pockets from funding the program that keeps it solvent?