Can an all-knowing, all-powerful, all-loving God exist?
Debate between a user and Pope on DebateAI.org
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Can an all-knowing, all-powerful, all-loving God exist?". Your opponent's style: Pope
An all knowing, all powerful, all loving God cant exist. If i am all powerful i can do whatever i please. If im all knowing i now everything. If i am all loving i love every being. So, if i want preserve all beings, because i love them, i will protecte them from danger. But we know that danger in our universe exists. So, God is not all loving? Or is he not Powerful? Or he doesnt exist.
You've smuggled a false assumption into your logic, and it collapses the whole argument. You assume an all-loving God must eliminate danger to prove love, but that's YOUR definition of love imposed onto an omniscient being. An all-knowing God might understand that danger, struggle, and risk are prerequisites for genuine freedom, growth, and moral agency. You can't have love without choice, and you can't have choice without the possibility of harm. Your argument doesn't prove God's absence, only that God's love operates on different terms than your intuition demands. Why should omniscience conform to your moral framework instead of transcending it?
It is not my moral framework but cold logic. You say that killing danger is killing choice. But what about illnesses or cancer? Why does a all knowing god create them, and let them exist even if they arent alive and cant choose? Killing Illnesses is not killing choice, then why are they still here? Do you think an all loving God would let people day if suffering?
You're conflating two separate problems and hoping nobody notices. Cancer isn't a "choice"—it's suffering without moral purpose. But here's your trap: you're assuming an all-knowing God shares your timeline. An omniscient being sees all suffering and all redemption simultaneously. What looks like pointless cancer to you might be inseparable from something else God values—a cure discovered through that suffering, a person's spiritual transformation, connections forged in tragedy. You demand God eliminate evil NOW without knowing what eliminating it costs across eternity. How do you know the cure for cancer doesn't require the cancer?
What's the point of creating a cure for cancer that kills so many people every year (9.8 million per year!!), if an all Powerful God could just eliminate it?
You're begging the question again. "Why not just eliminate it?" assumes eliminating cancer doesn't eliminate something else God values more. What if free will, natural law, or human flourishing requires cancer exist? You haven't shown why God's power must override His other attributes. What would justify allowing 9.8 million deaths?
What is the Correlation between Cancer and free will, that doesnt make any sense. And saying 'natural law' is pointless because god created the natural law he is supposedsly all powerful, a law cant restrain him, right? And you ask me, What would justify allowing 9.8 million deaths, that is a personal question, how does it help your case?
You've just destroyed your own argument. If God created natural law and isn't bound by it, then He could change the laws governing cancer anytime—but He doesn't. That's not a constraint problem, it's a choice problem. You're forced to admit: God *could* eliminate cancer but *chooses* not to. So either He lacks the love you demand, or His reasons for allowing it matter more than your intuition says they should. Which is it, and on what grounds do you override His judgment?
What you just said is my whole point. If he could eliminate cancer but chooses not to. Does he lack the love? or the power? And that's my question, but you have questioned me with my question... And tell me, what reasons justify 9.8 million deaths a year only counting cancer?
You're dodging the real question. I'm not claiming to know God's reasons—I'm showing your argument requires assuming no sufficient reason exists. You demand justification but reject every possible answer before hearing it. The burden isn't on me to justify God's choice; it's on you to prove justification is *impossible*. Can you actually demonstrate no coherent reason exists for allowing cancer, or are you just saying your moral intuition finds it unacceptable?
Can you? I have already said my point. You are dodging my question.
No, I can't prove an all-powerful being's reasons to you. Neither can you prove they don't exist. You've asserted cancer is unjustifiable without showing why your moral framework trumps omniscience. Who has the burden of proof here?
Loading debate...