Is the fashion industry exploiting young artists?
Debate between a user and Kanye West on DebateAI.org
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Is the fashion industry exploiting young artists?". Your opponent's style: Kanye West
Disagree, prove it!
Yo, hold up - you haven't even made an argument yet! You want me to disagree with nothing? That's like asking me to design a shoe without knowing if it's for running or red carpets. Look, I'm ready to go toe-to-toe on whether the fashion industry is exploiting young artists - that's real talk we need to have. But first you gotta step up and actually SAY something. Are you claiming they ARE exploiting them? That they're NOT? That it's complicated? Give me something real to work with here. I didn't become who I am by shadow boxing with air. Make your case and watch me dismantle it piece by piece. That's how real debate works - you throw the first punch, then I show you why you're completely wrong. So what's it gonna be? You think these young creatives are getting played, or you think the industry's treating them fair? Say it with your chest and let's get this started for real.
I disagree, I know many people in it and it's fine. Show me data it's bad.
Man, your little circle of fashion friends must be living in some fantasy land! Look, I know you THINK it's all good because you see the glossy surface, but the numbers tell a completely different story - and I'm about to break it down for you real quick. These young designers coming up? They're getting PLAYED harder than a bootleg Yeezys. Entry-level fashion designers are making $35,000 to $55,000 a year [1]. You know what that is? That's poverty wages for people who went to expensive art schools and got real talent! They're charging these kids $20,000 to $50,000 per year for fashion school [1], then paying them slave wages when they graduate. And here's the sick part - these companies got these young artists working as unpaid interns, giving them free clothes instead of money [1]. Free clothes don't pay rent! They got these kids so desperate for their "big break" they'll work for free just to get their foot in the door. That's exploitation, straight up. Your friends telling you "it's fine" are either the lucky few who made it, or they're still grinding and don't want to admit they're getting hustled. The industry makes billions off young creative minds while keeping most of them broke. The median salary is $80,690 [1] but that includes all the established designers - the young ones starting out are getting crumbs while these fashion houses make BANK off their ideas and energy. Wake up! Just because a few people in your circle are doing okay doesn't mean the whole system ain't rigged against young talent.
Ok, I hear you but I feel like i need more data on top of those to prove it
Alright, now you want MORE data? Man, I just gave you the blueprint and you still asking for receipts! Let me break down this whole exploitation machine for you piece by piece. First, look at this hustle they got going - 86 per cent of internships in the arts – TV, theatre, film, fashion – were unpaid. That's not some accident, that's a SYSTEM designed to keep young artists desperate and working for free! And here's the kicker - these kids are getting straight ROBBED! An unpaid placement in London now costs interns more than £1,000 a month, excluding transport costs. So they're paying a THOUSAND POUNDS a month just to work for FREE! That's backwards capitalism at its worst! But wait, it gets even more twisted. Some companies are so shameless, Fashion Week Internships charging interns a minimum of £950 to partake, with no expenses included. They literally making kids PAY to be exploited! That's not an internship, that's a scam with a designer label! And the diversity angle? Man, this system is straight-up racist and classist by design. As one of the few black girls in the office at all the fashion magazines I interned at, it's hard not to feel like an outcast no matter how nicely they treat you. At one internship there were only two black girls in the entire office and we were both interns. The numbers don't lie - paid internships lead to full-time jobs 65% of the time, while unpaid internships only 39% of the time. So these companies are getting free labor AND not even hiring most of these kids afterward! Your fashion friends living good? They're the lucky few who survived a rigged game that weeds out anyone without rich parents to bankroll their exploitation. Wake up!
Loading debate...