Should schools ban homework entirely?
Debate between a user and another high school student on DebateAI.org
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Should schools ban homework entirely?". Your opponent's style: another high school student
School shouldn't ban homework entirely. Students need it to practice at home and strengthen their understanding of the knowledge that they have learnt at school. It also increases learner autonomy
You're confusing "homework works" with "banning it is wrong." Practice matters, sure, but nothing about that requires homework specifically. Why can't schools embed that practice into class time with better pedagogy? What evidence shows take-home work beats in-class mastery?
I didn't say that take-home beats in-class mastery. I said that they should have homework to practice and the students can have the sense of responsibily to finish them
You're equivocating. "Practice" and "responsibility" are two separate claims, and you haven't justified either requires homework specifically. Students develop responsibility through countless other mechanisms. Why is homework the only vehicle for that, and why can't schools teach both during the school day?
You're assuming schools have infinite class time. They don't. A six-hour day is consumed by core instruction, transitions, and testing. Homework isn't about replacing responsibility lessons—it's the only realistic space where students actually *do* independent work under their own management. That's not equivocation, that's acknowledging practical constraints you're ignoring. And what is the point of banning homework? To save time so they can spend it on their hobbies at home?
You've just admitted the real problem: schools are structurally broken if they can't fit meaningful learning into six hours. Fixing that broken structure is the actual solution, not outsourcing it to families with wildly unequal resources. Poor kids with working parents get crushed by homework; rich kids get tutors. You're not teaching responsibility, you're amplifying inequality. Why should a flawed system's failures become a child's evening burden?
It's not six hours we are talking about. They only have 45 to 50 minutes for one lesson. That includes teaching and practicing the knowledge they have just learnt, it's not deep enough for them. And who says homework has to be heavy? It can be watching a video and make comments, or doing a digital game in which have the knowledge they learn at school that students actually enjoy
Now you're describing optional enrichment, not mandatory homework. Light, enjoyable tasks don't need a "ban" to disappear, they just need to stop being compulsory. Your real argument is that schools need *longer lessons* or *better-designed instruction*, not that homework solves it. If a 50-minute block isn't enough, extend it or restructure it. Why hide a systemic failure behind voluntary activities framed as homework instead of actually fixing the schedule?
Students' attention span can not extent that long. 50 minutes is enough for them to understand the lesson. The point why homework is needed for them to practice and strengthen knowledge at home. It is compulsory because teachers can assess them through their homework, not only through test.
You just contradicted yourself hard. If 50 minutes is "enough to understand," why isn't it enough to practice? You're saying homework is essential for assessment, but that's just lazy evaluation. Teachers can assess understanding through classwork, quizzes, discussions, projects. Making students do unpaid labor at home to generate gradebook data isn't pedagogically necessary, it's administratively convenient. What happens to your argument if teachers simply grade better during school?
What happened to review and prepare for class before going to school. Without homework, where will students get their knowledge to do discussions and projects, if there isn't any research homework or extra reading for them to do at homw
You're describing preparation work, not practice homework. Those are different things. If students need to research before class, that's optional pre-work students choose to do. You started arguing homework was mandatory for practice and responsibility, now you're saying it's for preparation. Which is it? Pick one claim and defend it properly.
Loading debate...