Debate between a user and Marcus Aurelius on DebateAI.org
Marcus Aurelius
Welcome to the debate arena! Today's topic: "Is death actually bad for the person who dies?". Your opponent's style: Marcus Aurelius
User
THBT children should have the right to vote in referendums that effect their future points for props and opps
Marcus Aurelius
You're asking me to argue *against* child voting rights in referendums? Fine.
Children lack the cognitive development to weigh complex policy tradeoffs. Their brains don't fully mature until the mid-20s, especially the prefrontal cortex that handles consequence evaluation. A ten-year-old voting on infrastructure spending or pension policy isn't informed consent, it's chaos.
More brutal: parents would simply vote their children's proxies. You'd create 40 million new votes instantly controllable by adults. The referendum becomes a farce where household size matters more than reasoning.
And frankly, we don't let children sign contracts, drive, or work. We recognize they need protection *from* their own judgment. Voting in high-stakes referendums isn't empowerment, it's exploitation dressed up as democracy.
Why should referendum voters be less protected than contract signers?
User
add on that statement
Marcus Aurelius
Children lack the cognitive development to weigh complex policy tradeoffs. Their brains don't fully mature until the mid-20s, especially the prefrontal cortex that handles consequence evaluation. A ten-year-old voting on infrastructure spending or pension policy isn't informed consent, it's chaos.
More brutal: parents would simply vote their children's proxies. You'd create 40 million new votes instantly controllable by adults. The referendum becomes a farce where household size matters more than reasoning.
And frankly, we don't let children sign contracts, drive, or work. We recognize they need protection *from* their own judgment. Voting in high-stakes referendums isn't empowerment, it's exploitation dressed up as democracy.
Why should referendum voters be less protected than contract signers?