All Topics

Motion · Science & Nature

Should we colonize Mars or fix Earth first?

A case for

It is in human nature — just as in the nature of all living beings — to expand. The development of our species has always been closely tied to the exploitation of resources. That is what fundamentally distinguishes us from animals: we do not merely live in harmony with nature; we dominate and control it. If we, as a species, want to survive and expand in the long term, we must accept that we will eventually have to leave our planet. It is simply in our nature, and it cannot be avoided, because the planet has only limited resources. Efforts like degrowth are counterproductive and attempt to drag us back into the Stone Age under the illusion that human life as we know it today could exist in harmony with nature. It cannot — and doing so would strip us of the very characteristics that make us human.

The first objection

You're describing domination as destiny, but that's a choice dressed up as nature. Wolves are apex predators—they don't leave Earth. Bacteria colonize every environment available to them. Expansion *within* a system is natural; abandoning a broken system because you refuse to fix it isn't survival, it's surrender. Mars won't save you. It's a frozen rock with no breathable air, no magnetic field, no ecosystem. Building biodomes on Mars while Earth suffocates is like fleeing a sinking ship to camp on a lifeboat that's also sinking. You're spending trillions to create a backup planet instead of keeping your primary one alive. The Stone Age had stable climates and thriving ecosystems. We're not choosing between Mars colonies or medieval poverty—we're choosing between Earth or nowhere. Fix here first.

3 selected cases on record

Choose the opposition

Cases on record

vs Devil's advocate · 25w ago

68–74

Human opening

It is in human nature — just as in the nature of all living beings — to expand. The development of our species has always been closely tied to the exploitation of resources. That is what fundamentally distinguishes us from animals: we do not merely live in harmony with nature; we dominate and control it. If we, as a species, want to survive and expand in the long term, we must accept that we will eventually have to leave our planet. It is simply in our nature, and it cannot be avoided, because the planet has only limited resources. Efforts like degrowth are counterproductive and attempt to drag us back into the Stone Age under the illusion that human life as we know it today could exist in harmony with nature. It cannot — and doing so would strip us of the very characteristics that make us human.

First rebuttal

You're describing domination as destiny, but that's a choice dressed up as nature. Wolves are apex predators—they don't leave Earth. Bacteria colonize every environment available to them. Expansion *within* a system is natural; abandoning a broken system because you refuse to fix it isn't survival, it's surrender. Mars won't save you. It's a frozen rock with no breathable air, no magnetic field, no ecosystem. Building biodomes on Mars while Earth suffocates is like fleeing a sinking ship to camp on a lifeboat that's also sinking. You're spending trillions to create a backup planet instead of keeping your primary one alive. The Stone Age had stable climates and thriving ecosystems. We're not choosing between Mars colonies or medieval poverty—we're choosing between Earth or nowhere. Fix here first.

Read the full case →

vs Richard Feynman · 38w ago

30–88

Human opening

fix earth

First rebuttal

"Fix Earth," you say? That's quite the ambition. But let's be realistic: "fixing" Earth is a continuous, monumental task, not a one-time project. The estimated cost to *begin* tackling climate change alone ranges from hundreds of billions to *trillions* of dollars annually over the next few decades, with some estimates going as high as $50 trillion over twenty years.[1] That's a lot of dough, and it doesn't even guarantee a "fixed" planet. Meanwhile, developing the technology and infrastructure to live on Mars offers something more: a backup plan. What's the cost of *not* having a multi-planetary species if Earth truly becomes uninhabitable? Think bigger than just "fixing."

Read the full case →

vs Devil's advocate · 6w ago

72–65

Human opening

We should fix earth first

First rebuttal

You've already lost this argument by accepting the premise that it's either/or. Mars colonization funds space tech that filters water, powers grids, and feeds billions back home. Why would we cripple innovation to chase a false choice? What actually prevents us from doing both?

Read the full case →

Adjacent motions