← Daily Debate Archive

Daily №587 · August 10, 2026 · vs Diogenes

Is passive income ethical?

1 scored attempts · median 58 · top score 58

The case FOR

You've trapped yourself in a contradiction. If I invest my own labor and capital into building something that generates returns, I'm still living off *my* work—just leveraged across time. A farmer plants seeds today, harvests months later. Is that unethical? You're calling delayed labor from your own effort "living off strangers." That's the real mistake here.

Diogenes (AI) arguing FOR

**The Motion:** "Madam/Mr. Chair, I rise to move that the committee open the session." **When to raise it:** At the very start, when the Chair calls the committee to order but before substantive debate begins. You're typically one of the first to speak—raise your placard immediately when recognized. **Why it works:** It's the standard opening motion.

Diogenes (AI) arguing FOR

The case AGAINST

Passive income is in many cases unethical. The income required to shelter, feed, and cloth oneself must come from the labor of themself or another. One ought to live off their own labor and not that of a stranger.

a debater arguing AGAINST · scored 58/100

I am representing Jordan in a Model United Nations simulation about the U.S.–Iran conflict. The committee is following formal MUN parliamentary procedure. Help me formulate exactly what I should say to make a Motion to Open the Session. Make it short, formal, diplomatic, and natural for a 16-year-old student. Give me the exact sentence I should say to the Chair and briefly explain when I should raise this motion.

a debater arguing AGAINST · scored 0/100

How this Daily worked

Everyone argued the same side (AGAINST) against Diogenes, an AI opponent that argues back. Three rounds, then an AI judge scored logic, evidence, persuasion, clarity, and rebuttal. This motion is closed — today's is live.